Skip to content
A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Is racism behind treatment of Haitians?

CLICK HERE FOR AN ARTICLE THAT POSES THIS SEEMINGLY AGE-OLD QUESTION:

The conference room at the law offices of Kurzban, Kurzban, Weinger and Tetzeli was crammed tight. Attorneys took turns at the microphone, their faces etched with frustration. The question they kept coming back to: Why? Why, they asked, are Haitian immigrants singled out by the U.S. government for unequal treatment? On this day, earlier in the year, the topic was temporary protected status, a designation the federal government can grant to foreigners allowing them to remain part time in the United States because of political unrest or environmental disasters at home. Central Americans have repeatedly been granted protected status following hurricanes and earthquakes in Nicaragua, Honduras and El Salvador. Immigrants from Burundi, Liberia, Somalia and Sudan also enjoy such protections. But Haitians have never obtained relief, despite decades of political turmoil, kidnappings and killings, and tribulations from tropical storms.

***

One can only wonder how much race and racism affects all of U.S. immigration law and enforcement.  yes, the immigration laws for the most part are race neutral.  However, the law and its enforcement has racially disparte impacts.  And just how much anti-Mexican sentiment is affecting the debate over immigration reform?  I sure wish I could say “not at all” but that would be a lie.

KJ