Skip to content
A Member of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Driver’s Licenses an Issue in Democratic Presidential Debate

The Democratic candidates debated in the historic city of Phiadelphia last night.  Driver’s license eligibility came up.  Here is the MSNC report:

“[Sen. Christopher] Dodd . . . was the only candidate who raised his hand when Brian Williams, managing editor and anchor of `NBC Nightly News,’ asked whether anyone believed illegal immigrants should not have driver’s licenses. “This is a privilege, not a right,” he said. Clinton may have given her opponents an opening to bear down on their “doubletalk” attack. In a convoluted answer to the same question, Clinton first said she thought New York Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s plan to let illegal immigrants have driver’s licenses “makes a lot of sense.” Then she said she did not endorse Spitzer’s plan even though she repeated that he had the right idea. Then she accused Russert of asking a “gotcha” question. Edwards leaped, noting that Clinton appeared to have given two different answers in less than two minutes. “I think this is a real issue for the country,” he said. “I mean, America is looking for a president who will say the same thing, who will be consistent, who will be straight with them.””

For more on the debate, including a link to a video of the entire debate, click here.  According to Frank Luntz’s Democratic Focus Group, Senator Obama was the “overwhelming” winner of last night’s debate.  See Video at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L8ocKiHEzvM

Postscript Some readers may want to look at Lou Dobbs’ latest — a critique of NY Governor Spitzer’s position on driver’s license eligibilty for undocumented immigrants.  Dobbs has been conducting war on Gov. Spitzer, calling him an “idiot,” among other things.  As I said before, the national safety/public safety argument for denial of driver’s licenses to certain groups of drivers makes no sense to me.  I want all driver’s on the road to be safety tested and to have liabilty insurance.

KJ